After a Trump tweet, Justice Department reverses position on including a citizenship question in the census

  • 📰 NBCNews
  • ⏱ Reading Time:
  • 43 sec. here
  • 2 min. at publisher
  • 📊 Quality Score:
  • News: 20%
  • Publisher: 86%

Law Law Headlines News

Law Law Latest News,Law Law Headlines

JUST IN: After President Trump tweets, government reverses course on citizenship census question.

Dareh Gregorian and Adam Edelman

“We are absolutely moving forward, as we must, because of the importance of the answer to this question,” Trump added. The judge ordered an update by 2 p.m. ET Friday, and suggested that if he were not satisfied, he could issue an order barring the citizenship question from being asked.Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross said in a statement Tuesday that the Census Bureau has started printing the decennial questionnaires without the question, saying that he “strongly" disagreed with the high court's ruling.

The director of the Census Bureau, Dr. Steven Dillingham, will testify before the House Subcommittee on Civil Rights and Civil Liberties about the status of the agency's planning and preparations for the 2020 census, the panel's chairman, Rep. Jamie Raskin, D-Md., said Wednesday.Rep. Grace Meng, D-N.Y.

 

Thank you for your comment. Your comment will be published after being reviewed.
Please try again later.

The long form questionnaire asked a citizenship question up until 2000, when the Obama administration dropped it. Why would adding it back again be considered unconstitutional?

Yes, SCOTUS turned down the 1st request but did say it was constitutional if given good reason. Did put that in the click bait did ya?

How the hell are we going to know how many of us are PAYING ALL THE BILLS!!

'I dont care about law. I want what I want.'

FuckTrump IllegitimatePresident TrumpRussia PutinsBitch TrumpCrimeFamily TrumpMustGo

Republicans don't give a shit what the supreme court says, the scumbag, McConnell, and the rest of the dictator republicans will take the country over, hell they're already 3/4 of the way there. Stupid people supporting them think it would be good but they won't like it either.

The tyrant realDonaldTrump says “All shall obey my whims despite the law.” And the weak obey in fear they will bruise his ego.

Is there *anybody* in this administration who isn’t a filthy liar?

Never give up, Never surrender...

No backbone

No longer a republic.

I can't help but agree with the DOJ that without the citizenship question, there is no other way to count the number of citizens in our country. I don't know why some folks find it offensive or irrelevant? But we have way too many people who challenge all good/bad issues.

The Census is done to get an idea of the number of citizens there are. I don't ever remember getting a questionnaire. I do remember high tension in Oregon when Census takers came, and visited all of the private property to get a head count. It was dangerous for all involved.

Always thought SCOTUS had the last word. Not according to Trump I hear. If only we had a constitutional scholar for a president, we wouldn't be having this ongoing issue.

Another above the law! Trump dictator move!

You’re gonna have a lot of people not filling it out

If the supreme court does it job .... ya can’t jerkass

What article fails to state is the SC rejected the JD’s argument saying its narrowly tailored defense using the 1965 Voting Act was not sufficient, but the SC would entertain additional evidence & reconsider the decision if the JD wanted to re-submit. The SC left the door open.

Trump wants a “legal” approach ? 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

So now he's going to ignore the Supreme Court too. He must be very disappointed in the ruling, considering he thought he had the court bought and paid for. Just when does the GOP start to et concerned?

Defying Congress(subpoenas) AND the Supreme Court(ruling about census question) AND the Constitution(the census must be taken). No one left, we live in a Banana Republic. With TANKS on the Streets. What am I missing?

The Supreme Court did not say No to the citizenship question, but the media lies have fooled many people. Since there was not a hard No, of course the White House will continue to fight. The media needs to stop lying to makeup stories to promote hate. Hate is wrong!

After reading the transcript from today’s call, the judge is not happy. There was agreement after SCOTUS ruling, now the gov’t is backpedaling cause trump won’t accept NO. Like a child, when told No, he just goes off in a different direction, ignoring the No. Gotta go in 2020...

He thought he bought the SC. Glad in this particular instance his purchase was not effective. Yet - Trump does not abide by the law. He lies, cheats, gropes, evades....

Even the most POTUS-power-heavy SCOUS judge, not even the 'Trump Judges' can't think his high horse egotistical ignorant disregard for how our system works & what the constitution demands to faithfully uphold our laws...He's unqualified, ignorant & unfit to serve as POTUS.

Yeah...all by Friday.....

It'll happen on the follow-ups. Little marks they'll put on the forms. Like minded census workers will go along with it. A box with no question next to it looks like nothing but to trained eyes. They'll spook people which is as good as a NO

The ONLY question that should be on any US census should be 'How many people are in your household?'. Any other question is political bovine excrement.

Take one for our US citizens and don’t do it.

a ruling that sent the case back to a lower court.

I think it’s time to call for a national boycott of-if not the entire census-the citizenship question at the least.

Lawless bastards. Ef these guys.

Pulling an Andrew Jackson. I guess Trump finally found a Democrat he likes.

Let’s stop fooling ourselves. Roberts gave them a chance to clean up these racist reasons. Just like they did numerous times to finally get the Muslim ban passed.

Plz vote foe me in 2020 if it's winter time plz wear your gloves thanks

SCOTUS 'Trumps' dictators Donnie. Games over, your tantrum means nothing.

Give me back that old crappy America I knew before trump. F him and his new America. Where oversight means nothing. Before tanks and Nazi rolled over streets. That’s the America I grew up loving.

He’ll go down in history as the most corrupt and evil person to ever hold the presidency. How people do not see this is baffling.

In other words. “We have to come up with another lie to tell SCOTUS

No..SCOTUS ruled NO!

This is Democrats’ way of keeping Mexico interfering in our elections by allowing illegals to pad their electoral votes.

So the JUSTICE DEPARTMENT will comply with a demented dictador wannabe.

Dictatorship in 3... 2... 1...

In other words illegally. Impeach.

Good! Shouldn't we know who is in our country NBC you suck by the way for not broadcasting our President's show tomorrow. You are bought and paid for and have no balls.

Hey Donald you aren’t above the Supreme Court. Remember the 3 branches of government?

NO means no. Is he really that freakin stupid?

So SCOTUS ruling means nothing?

Supreme Court rules.

What the hell is a census without a citizenship question. Might as well send to every country in the world.👎🏽

Tell the orange ass “NO”

The dictator has spoken

Be nice if the Justice Dept metered out justice, instead of political loyalty..

Trump = unhinged lunatic: lose canon posing the greatest threat to our national & local security, portraying the worst of us. He's an embarrassment & stain on our country, our history & what we stand for. Trump as POTUS is the biggest failed experiment. End this disasterous era.

This is absolutely terrible for this country.

Supreme Court ruled. Who do they think they are?

The ship of state is being 'steered' by the tweets of narcissistic conman so dementia-riddled he frequently doesn't even realize when he's shit his Depends. Just wanted to see what our current reality looked like actually typed out. 😕

He is governing by Twitter. Unacceptable

This just in... all illegal immigrants ask, 'well, what if we just say we're citizens and fill it out anyway?'

So sick

TheJusticeDept IA BIG JOKE

I pray NO ONE FILLS THEM OUT. I KNOW MY FAMILY WILL NOT BE.

Fake news!! NBC

realDonaldTrump hmmm what happened to the DOJ’s Independence? trump u corrupt dotard.

Future infrastructure,security,food supplies etc are based on that question.Why would the dems want false numbers it would destroy America

A question which is about helping the future of the country. A better future for all Americans. Dems sabotage everything just to spite Trump

So “illegal” immigrants can obtain drivers license (in my state), health care and countless other handouts but they shouldn’t be required to answer honestly about their citizen status on the census!!

Make it happen!!! MAGA! gone are the days that the sanctuary states are getting higher electoral votes/house seats because of the millions illegals who live there. Crack down on sanctuary states and this is step 1! Then the fed gov cuts support of states to pressure governors

Leave it the fuck alone!

Enough SpeakerPelosi Impeach this tyrant now.

trump should know that if he gets re-elected the chances he’ll be impeached are like 99% because all the reasons not to impeach him will be gone, and the dems will be looking to “get right” with history, if he was smart he’d try and figure out how to lose and get out

Nice!

Congratulations NBC you have filled your followers with the wrong belief that the SCOTUS struck down the question. They didn’t, they simply allowed the case to proceed in the lower court hence the court appearance Friday. To all the folks screaming Trump overruled the court

They have to cheat to cling to power They are tyrants They are corrupt They must be put out of power

Just learned on DeanObeidallah show why this is so dangerous: Congressional district maps are drawn based upon census results (representation by population, regardless of citizenship status). Maps drawn by those in power will cater 10 years worth to those in power.

Really, do u think u could write a factual lead-in? How : T admin tries AGAIN to circumvent the justice system & our Constitution in another attempt to weaken our democracy.

For those calling for SpeakerPelosi to impeach this law-breaking POTUS, call instead in senatemajldr Mitch McConnell. Because the Republican Senate, not Pelosi will block the impeachment of Trump. And dictator Trump will take a victory lap when they do.

So the DOJ capitulated to DT. So much for a working democracy. There are no more checks and balances.

Ignoring the Supreme Court? Impeach and throw him jail

Good. He needs to fight this.

Let’s gooooooo!

ImpeachTheMFTraitor

WAY TO GO MR PRESIDENT.! REAL AMERICANS ARE BEHIND YOU 100%.

This madness needs to stop. How can Congress and DOJ allow him to ignore a Supreme Court ruling?

If you can not answer the question YOU SHOULD NOT BE HERE! 🇺🇸☝️🦅💪

Well....he and his administration has ignored EVERY law in the book and gotten away with it so far...why would they stop now? They are setting an 'amazing' example for the young generation of America....if you are White and rich, the rule of law does not apply!

Outstanding!!!

Such B.S.!

Shows how corrupt the system is, trump says jump barr says how high

f$ck these people. all of them.

States that want to gain control of the Federal Government are pushing to keep the question off as they ignore rules concerning immigrant status and fight protecting our border knowing the Census will grant them more House Seats and Electoral votes robbing from middle America!

Good!

Only cause he needs this to gerrymander the areas were other than whites live thus subverting elections. Talk about stealing elections by deep state! This is it. Trump is to dumb for this look inside the Rep. party. ABC CBSNews CNN MSNBC USSenate SpeakerPelosi USHouse

lachic288 Following the directions of a madman

“Justice” department huh? Looks like that ship has sailed. We are full on banana republic.

The question is NYB.

THIS is Presidental harassment

So the bigger picture here is that Moron Trump Tweeting is an official form of contact for the government. People can now use it as a form of government legislation.

It means they are challenging the ruling.

It wasn’t a ruling saying they can’t add it, it was a ruling stating they needed a better reason to add it.

Great News!

The Supreme Court ruled that the reason to add the question wasn’t enough, they left the door open to make a better reason in adding it.

Despicable. Tweets shouldn’t be considered directives.

Congress should quote one of DJT’s own tweets; “you lost, no do overs”.

It will be returned to sender. Your dime, not mine. Tired of you wasting my tax dollars on this FAKE person in our White.

The Department of “Justice”

The executive branch has gone rogue. ImpeachTrump

Irish016206 How insane must countries be to NOT ask for citizenship on a census form.

Throw the whole census and he who must not be named to the garbage

AWESOME! 🇱🇷🇱🇷🇱🇷🇱🇷👍

This is a senseless news story that makes absolutely no sense.

realDonaldTrump deliver his own FakeTweet that Congress has put that question back on during the election race.

He did say that the earlier claims by the media were FAKE. Take heed in future.

Judge ordered some answers on Friday. The transcript is 🔥🔥🔥.

Of course, your president thinks he’s above the law, above the constitution and above the people. Sad 4 years for America.

There are no options left for them that doesn’t put them at odds with the SC decision.

Time to Impeach

Let the dumbass do what he wants with this question. If no one else will stop him, WE CAN. I will not answer that question - simply skip it. Everyone do the same. Fight back! SenateGOP HouseGOP SenateDems HouseDemocrats DOJ 2020Census realDonaldTrump

Will not answer the question

realDonaldTrump why hasn't some of the coward Republicans gone to look at the conditions at these migrant camps and speak out about these horrible conditions.

Under His Eye...

Why don’t we all lie and say we have like four extra people in our houses to make up for the disenfranchised?

How stupid you NBCNightlyNews can be. President realDonaldTrumpnis the head of the government. And he has the authority to reverse or direct the government’s direction. Biased to give you the benefited of the doubt. Ignorant more likely. RealDrGina newtgingrich

I’ll say I’m not a citizen even though I’m a citizen

The face and actions of a spoiled, immature, pathetic old white man. Whether it is right or wrong, only his way counts. Again, trying to rig polling data and census counts to help himself win. Coward, traitor, criminal. The are Trump's correct titles.

Its because trump has the justice system by the ball and they are afraid of his ire

SpeakerPelosi how about now?

What is he ? Dictator trump um un ?

The 'Grand' Dragon' has spoken.

Maybe he can delay it until and adult becomes president again

He’s right. They ask you when you go to Jury Duty of your citizenship

Hell of a way to run a railroad! Good grief, the right hand doesn't know what the left hand is doing!

So . . . the TrumpCrimeFamily is ignoring subpoenas from the Legislative Branch AND rulings by the Judiciary Branch . . . just because that’s what they do.

resign

Now someone tell me he wont be elected! He is the only one that gets it done!

Democrats gonna be losing votes!!! 😂😂😂😂😂

Wait what He’s going to just ignore the Supreme Court now? And that’s not in your headline?

Shocker Dictator Wanna Be defies the Supreme Court, time to kick him the hell out of the White House

He’s so easily played.

So Trump Admin ignores Congressional subpoenas and now the SCOTUS. Trump absolutely thinks he's above the law and nobody is holding him accountable.

Now what?

Trump: I wanna do a thing Law: You can't do that thing, it's unconstitutional Trump: Don't care, I will break the law to do the thing Also Trump: That infant belongs in a cage because it broke the law

We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here. Read more:

 /  🏆 10. in LAW

Law Law Latest News, Law Law Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

Trump administration reverses course on census citizenship questionIn a major reversal, the Justice Department told a federal judge in Maryland on Wednesday that it has been 'instructed to examine whether there is a path forward consistent with the Supreme Court's decision, that would allow us to include the citizenship question on the census.' The Justice Department told a federal judge in Maryland that it has been 'instructed to examine whether there is a path forward consistent with the Supreme Court's decision, that would allow us to include the citizenship question on the census.' Why bother with annoyances like the constitution and Supreme Court when you have tRump in the White House THIS IS WHY HE MUST BE IMPEACHED NOW!!! Total disregard for the rule of law. Can't wait until 2021 when the Democrat president does everything by executive order and I'll be fine with it. Executive Order 1: McConnell removed from office!! Let's go there!!
Source: CNN - 🏆 4. / 95 Read more »