President Donald Trump's top administration lawyer clashed with liberal justices of the Supreme Court on Tuesday over the government's plan to add a citizenship question to the 2020 census.
How the justices rule will impact the decennial count which determines how congressional seats are apportioned, how many electoral votes each state receives in a presidential election and how billions in taxpayer dollars are distributed on a per capita basis. Three lower federal courts found that Ross acted illegally -- in an"arbitrary and capricious" manner -- circumventing the Administrative Procedures Act, which requires federal agencies to carefully study all relevant evidence and facts pertaining to a problem before implementing a new policy. The agency must also publicly lay out the reasons for a decision and allow public comment.
"It did seem like he was shopping for a need. You can't read this recommendation without thinking that this need was a contrived one," Kagan told Francisco. "The UN says be careful and test the question to ensure that it doesn't hurt the enumeration," countered Barbara Underwood, solicitor general for the state of New York."It's useful information for a country to have. The question is, should it be included on an instrument to get a count.""You're right. But we've had demographic questions on the Census -- sex, age, do you own a house or own a radio?" Roberts said.
"An undercount would threaten at least one of California's seats in the House of Representatives -- and, by extension -- an elector in the electoral college," said California attorney general Xavier Beccera."It would deprive California and its cities and counties of their fair share of billions of dollars in federal funds."
Don’t take a census, proves Trump read the Bible!! Old Testanent, Don’t take a census, well maybe he should after all, Trump has no religious foundation except 1 Satan!
Asking the question is stupid.
There are a few questions in the census that are objectionable. Over reach
SenSchumer
sfpelosi
Isn't this just another way to report people to ICE? I don't understand the reason for the citizenship question except to locate and deport people. The census is about the people currently living in the US. Period.
No. Trump refused a LEGAL order by forcing Treasury to withhold.
I think enough US citizens should refuse to participate with this sham of a Census if the Supreme Court allows Trump and Ross to have this senseless question added; which only serves to discourage undocumented people from being included, as constitutionally mandated.
'The conservative majority seemed untroubled by the addition of the question'. Game over fellas, Trump wins.
We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here. Read more:
Law Law Latest News, Law Law Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
The Supreme Court will weigh a challenge to the citizenship question on the 2020 censusThe legal debate has echoes of last year’s battle over the travel ban Of more import than federal dollars and congressional seats is accurate data from which researchers analyze issues of sociology, economics, medicine, and other sciences. Very concerned Scotus will vote on political rather than research consequences of decision. It is a census of United States citizens. It impacts representation in the House of Representatives. How can you not ask and get a solid and representative census? Will we hear from, or see RBG ? WheresRuth
Source: TheEconomist - 🏆 6. / 92 Read more »
Supreme Court to decide if Trump administration can ask about citizenship in 2020 censusThe US Supreme Court hears its highest profile case of the term Tuesday — a battle over the Trump administration's plan to add a citizenship question to the 2020 census form that goes to every US household. Everyone just answer, yes. We say they can ask about citizenship once Trump proves that Obama was born in Kenya, he proves that he and his wife are citizens and turns over his tax returns that have been under “routine audit” for three years... This should actually help those sanctuary states to receive more funding , I don’t think it should be an issue. The only issue I have is voters should have an ID that shows citizenship, judicial Watch found over a million illegal votes
Source: NBCNews - 🏆 10. / 86 Read more »
Supreme Court to decide fate of citizenship question on 2020 censusSupreme Court to decide fate of citizenship question on 2020 census. Until 1950, the census regularly asked about citizenship status, a practice discontinued 70 years ago over concerns it harmed participation. Government intelligence going backwards, whats next removing womens right to vote? Reinstating slavery? I vote northern states become part of Canada...
Source: ABC - 🏆 471. / 51 Read more »
Demonstrators protest 2020 census question outside Supreme CourtAs the Supreme Court justices hear oral arguments over the 2020 census citizenship question, protesters have gathered outside the building to demand the controversial question is removed. marianaatencio Pretty sure the LAST thing that SCOTUS is supposed to care about is what the squeaky wheel thinks. marianaatencio Only citizens should be counted in the census because census data is used to determine how many electoral votes a state gets. States shd not get Electoral votes based on head counts that contain ineligible voters. marianaatencio Yikes! SCOTUS will be using the backdoor....
Source: MSNBC - 🏆 469. / 51 Read more »
Supreme Court looks likely to back Trump administration on adding citizenship question to 2020 censusA closely divided Supreme Court appeared almost certain Tuesday to allow the Trump administration to ask about citizenship in the 2020 census. What is to prevent people from falsifying that information? I'm American! Red, White and Blue. Old Glory and Apple Pie through and through. I hope we all feel better now. the census is conducted by the government of USA elected by its citizens, no?
Source: USATODAY - 🏆 100. / 63 Read more »
Supreme Court Reveals Deep Divisions on 2020 Census Citizenship QuestionThe Supreme Court appeared deeply divided on whether the Trump administration can ask U.S. residents on the 2020 census whether they are citizens. seems like a basic question. Why wouldn’t a country have the right to know if the people living there are citizens or not? Seems like a very reasonable question to me. There is no divide. Are you Republican, or are you a Democrat? That's all you need to know to vote. Party first. That is their solemn oath.
Source: WSJ - 🏆 98. / 63 Read more »
Supreme Court appears likely to allow citizenship question in 2020 censusDuring arguments today, the US Supreme Court's conservative majority seemed willing to let the Trump admin. add the question about citizenship to the 2020 census form. no no no How is that offensive, to see how many US citizens there are? Winning!
Source: MSNBC - 🏆 469. / 51 Read more »
Breaking down the 2020 census citizenship question debateAs the Supreme Court weighs a ruling on whether the 2020 census can include a question on U.S. citizenship, NBC News' Pete Williams breaks down the debate and why he thinks the justices will ultimately side with the government, allowing the question on the upcoming census. PeteWilliamsNBC Illegals do not deserve representation. It’s that simple PeteWilliamsNBC PeteWilliamsNBC Maybe they should ask if you're a Christian too? 🤣
Source: MSNBC - 🏆 469. / 51 Read more »
Supreme Court girds for fight over Trump census citizenship questionA sign on its front door in a heavily Hispanic neighborhood of the borough of Queens warns law enforcement officers not to enter without a warrant. Its colorful lobby is filled with butterfly-shaped placards made for protests against the hardline immigration policies of President Donald Trump, a fellow Girds...? Supreme Court encircles? Eh...
Source: YahooNews - 🏆 380. / 59 Read more »
Trump on track for Supreme Court victory on census citizenship questionThe U.S. Supreme Court's conservative majority on Tuesday appeared inclined to hand President Donald Trump a victory on his administration's plan to add a citizenship question to the 2020 census. I'm not sure why a citizenship question would be unconstitutional, especially considering it's been on there before. D's gonna get f*cked by the Supremes & Would Undermining A US Election come as some sort of surprise from this Deplorably Nefarious Admin. Run By a Narcissistic, Megalomaniacal, Bullying Con-Man-in-Chief?!
Source: CNBC - 🏆 12. / 72 Read more »
Supreme Court poised to give Trump victory on census citizenship questionConservative U.S. Supreme Court justices appeared sympathetic during opening arguments toward a bid by the Trump administration to add a citizenship query on the 2020 census via ReutersTV if there's no citizenship question we will boycottCensus2020 Census2020 No citizenship question no Census Interesting you bring up Trump trying to ask people whether they're citizens or not and not, say, Obama locking kids in cages, providing weapons to Mexican cartels on the border or deporting more people than any other president... Obama is full of it. He's just creating conflict where he could have fixed the problem. Typical crap and blame someone else
Source: Reuters - 🏆 2. / 97 Read more »