Inside the Johnny Doc jury room: All but one juror voted to acquit the labor leader in extortion case, panel member says

Inside the Johnny Doc jury room: All but one juror voted to acquit the labor leader in extortion case, panel member says

The juror’s account also provided new insights into how the jury of six men and six women viewed the government’s evidence as prosecutors weigh whether to retry Dougherty, the twice-convicted former head of But what prosecutors described as extortion, defense lawyers dismissed as a fistfight blown up into a meritless federal case. Eventually, those arguments held sway with most of the panel, the juror who spoke to The Inquirer said.As deliberations got underway just after 11 a.m. on April 25, seven members of the panel were leaning toward finding Dougherty and Fiocca guilty — though most of those jurors acknowledged they were open to being swayed.

While the contractor continued to pay Fiocca after the scuffle, the 18 paychecks that followed, each tied to a single extortion count, were for varying amounts of hours worked — a sign, according to the juror, that it “seemed like they were paying him for the hours he was there.” “It really just came down to personal feelings toward Greg and John — they weren’t good people,” the juror said. “They couldn’t separate that from the more factual information the rest of us were looking at.”“People were starting to realize we might be in here longer than anticipated, like we’ll be here all night,” the juror said. “People were definitely getting frustrated.

Still, they all had the sense that there was “something more” to the labor leader’s history than what they were being shown in court, the juror said.At least one member of the panel, the juror added, questioned whether the extortion case would have been brought at all if Dougherty were not already under investigation for something else.

Law Law Latest News, Law Law Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

The tale of the tape edition | Inside Johnny Doc’s TrialIt’s safe to say Dougherty's nephew, Greg Fiocca, isn't winning any “employee of the month” awards. But have defense lawyers done enough in court to help him and his uncle win the case?
Source: PhillyInquirer - 🏆 81. / 68 Read more »

The mistrial madness edition | Inside Johnny Doc’s TrialWith no verdict and no decision on whether John Dougherty's extortion case will be tried again, we break down what happens next and a possible reason behind the jury's indecision.
Source: PhillyDailyNews - 🏆 89. / 67 Read more »

Johnny Doc extortion trial to resume today with longtime Local 98 electrician on the standFederal trial of ex-Philly labor leader John Dougherty and his nephew, Greg Fiocca, could wrap up this week.
Source: PhillyDailyNews - 🏆 89. / 67 Read more »

Ex-Philly labor leader Johnny Doc's extortion trial to resume today with more testimonyWith the trial in its second week, prosecutors are focusing on John Dougherty's reaction to his nephew's job-site fight.
Source: PhillyDailyNews - 🏆 89. / 67 Read more »