, found that the states did have standing, and issued a nationwide injunction suspending the program while the case moved through the courts.
The court heard arguments about two legal issues in these cases: whether the parties opposing the loan forgiveness plan had standing Jackson said that MOHELA’s “financial interests are totally disentangled from the state, it stands alone, it’s incorporated separately, the state is not liable for anything that happens to MOHELA, I don’t know how that could possibly be a reason to say that an injury to MOHELA should count as an injury to the state.”
Kagan added, “You couldn’t even get documents from MOHELA without filing the state equivalent of a FOIA [Freedom of Information Act] request.”Brown alleged she was excluded from the debt relief program because her loan was privately held. Taylor, the other plaintiff, who would be eligible for $10,000 in debt cancellation, asserted that he was not eligible for $20,000 because he didn’t have a Pell Grant.
But Roberts, Thomas, Alito, Gorsuch and Kavanaugh strongly indicated that they bought the states’ argument that MOHELA gave them standing. When the court wants to decide a case on the merits, it invariably finds the parties have standing. Roberts was unconvinced that the program was a modification of existing student loan programs. “We’re talking about half a trillion dollars and 43 million Americans. How does that fit under the normal understanding of ‘modifying’?”
We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here. Read more:
Law Law Latest News, Law Law Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Student-Loan Forgiveness: Five Takeaways from Supreme Court Hearings1\. The Conservative Majority Appeared Skeptical of Biden’s Plan All six of the conservative justices at times appeared skeptical of the Biden administration’s main argument—that a 1. If they really cared Nancy wouldn’t have produced a bill while she was the speaker. $500B!? How much goes to students who attended for profit ripp-off schools? What they never mention is Congress is in charge of the money & they could set aside $'s to help on this. Instead they play the game of Biden offering it, knowing it will be unconstitutional & shot down by Scotus. It's a scam. They don't really want to help.
Source: WSJ - 🏆 98. / 63 Read more »
Supreme Court student loan hearing: What you need to knowConservative Justice Brett Kavanaugh pointed out Congress had declined to pass student loan relief, so Biden did it himself. That, he said, 'seems problematic.' 'forgiveness' lol Win-Win for the Dem’s regardless of the decision. If it’s found to be unconstitutional, those who are fiscally conservative minded will be blamed and demonized. Where can I apply to have my mortgage and car payment forgiven?
Source: ABC7Chicago - 🏆 284. / 63 Read more »
Supreme Court student loan hearing: What you need to knowConservative Justice Brett Kavanaugh pointed out Congress had declined to pass student loan relief, so Biden did it himself. That, he said, 'seems problematic.' Cancel all home mortgages while your at it. Car payments, Home mortgages, ATM fees, Credit Card fees, bills, taxes - Cancel them ALL!!!
Source: ABC7NY - 🏆 592. / 51 Read more »
Supreme Court student loan hearing: What you need to knowConservative Justice Brett Kavanaugh pointed out Congress had declined to pass student loan relief, so Biden did it himself. That, he said, 'seems problematic.' as I recall like democrats keep reminding us about trumps WALL to secure the border . . . the HOUSE controls the peoples purse . . not the president! ! while I would say 3 billion to stop a foreign INVASSION would be of national interest, GIFTING almost 500,000,000.oo not so much Yeah, well, his sexual assaults seem problematic too. Who paid conservative Justice Brett Kavanaugh‘s personal debts of $200,000 off for him in 2016? I mean, they just vanished in thin air. Education is not free. Where the money coming from, huh?
Source: abc7newsbayarea - 🏆 529. / 51 Read more »
Fate of Biden's student loan forgiveness plan to be decided by Supreme CourtThe Supreme Court is set to hear arguments Tuesday over President Joe Biden's student debt relief plan, which was paused after facing immense criticism.
Source: fox28columbus - 🏆 249. / 63 Read more »