Thuli Madonsela weighs in on JSC chief justice recommendation

  • 📰 TimesLIVE
  • ⏱ Reading Time:
  • 16 sec. here
  • 2 min. at publisher
  • 📊 Quality Score:
  • News: 10%
  • Publisher: 59%

Law Law Headlines News

Weighing in on the recommendation, Madonsela pointed out the decision on who would be the next chief justice would be made by the president alone, and he is not bound by the recommendation.

Former public protector Thuli Madonsela said appointing a chief justice is different to appointing a Supreme Court of Appeal president. File photo.Former public protector Thuli Madonsela sparked debate — and criticism from some — on social media after her statement on the recommendation that Supreme Court of Appeal president Mandisa Maya be appointed chief justice.

She was one of four candidates to be interviewed. The other three were acting chief justice Raymond Zondo, Constitutional Court justice Mbuyiseli Madlanga and Gauteng judge president Dunstan Mlambo. She added that appointing a chief justice is different to appointing a Supreme Court of Appeal president.

 

Thank you for your comment. Your comment will be published after being reviewed.
Please try again later.

And it will a Ramaphosa and his corrupt and incompetent cadre's one. Who will be complicit for the high-sounding title and enormously-greedy salary.

Ooooh so there are recommendations that are not binding ? Or is it just that tbis recommendation doesn't sit well with you Thuli?

Intombi ebukekayo madoda

Yes, he is bound by CR17STATEMENTS!

Problem with Rama is that he does not make decisions...and gets told by his handlers ( Cabal )....what to do.

I knew she will not say anything about Mandisa Maya to be the first female CJ this one is...

The ever sensible Mam Madonsela 🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓

it is now clear that Maya is not on WMC payroll in this banana republic

When e-wallet was still flowing

HonourableHloni Momma u keep on disappointing us. We need to respect u but uare waaaaaaaaaaaaaay lost. mara re tlaren u are sold. iyoooo we lost a leader in you.

HonourableHloni Truth hurts

Another colonial clerk, tea girl of the cabal blowing hot as as usual, but we as blacks have woken up to such realities hence we wi keep beating the dogs so hard and their handlers will eventually come out ✊🏿

Shame this lady

She only says that because it is not her that is nominated. This woman is bitter shame

Who is she Tsek

HonourableHloni Ungangidluli Jesu!!! Ngabe kwakhala nyonini.

HonourableHloni Prof they are going to hate you please don’t tell that because law and them it’s water and oil

HonourableHloni Advocate of Wikipedia articles must just relax please!!

Thuli Mandonsela and Ramaphosa belongs to a group that clearly is hellbent in selling the state to WMC Mafia's, a time will come for them to answer to the people of this country

If he doesn't approve the 1st female CJ then we'll know it wasn't his decision alone. Judging by the noise

Thuli Madonsela has this tendency of thinking she is a hubs of recommendations. Anything this woman says is a danger and a threat to this country. One day her real motives will be revealed.

Her opinion is not cast in stone.

person who just got his LLB 12 months ago

Stellies blackwhite girl, she should ashamed of her self. Trying to impress the minority.. Sies🚮

Not sure why Madonsela's view is valuable. She now has a weekly column in this paper with arguments to counter the winds of black emancipation. We see you

Her opinion is a non factor.

A Potato is a Potato, I don't understand this thing of these so called professors who are brought into our screens and newspapers to act smart and tell us something we all know. A recommendation is a recommendation and we all know and we haven't said it's not a recommendation. Nx

So she doesn't support another woman to take over Supporting the white privilege

Some ppl believe that the President's role in appointing the justice is ceremonial

I'm sure we all know that, but that doesn't stop JC to make the recommendations. They have done it before and I'm sure they will continue to do so in the future.

I wish this woman keep quiet.Cause each time she opens her mouth it's all nonsense

So a recommendation is just a recommendation as was ones said? 🤔🤔

The PresidencyZA can still select Judge Maya - without taking the recommendations of JSC! 🤷🏾🤷🏾🤷🏾 Why are people arguing as though it's given that CyrilRamaphosa will choose a different CJ? 🤷🏾

Pained is what she is, she's pained oh and another thing her time passed akame kancane yena man mxm

Tsek!

Ridiculous hogwash

Why do keep tell us what Thuli thinks as if, she's an expert.

F Madonsela

Mthengisi omdala lo

This is a joke to the South African

Enablers of Apartheid do not have shame T all. Apartheid was declared crime against humanity by the United nations.

Stellenbosch puppets are all over talking garbage

Zonda is the best candidate. All the corrupt are exposed. Stolen taxpayers money meant for South Africans especially for the poor and now stolen. You can see now the hatred for him from the ones who got away with it . It’s time to clean up and lock the rubbish away. Zonda 👍

Few month ago I was struggling to fend for my self and my kids ,at my last bus stop I decided to give Bitcoin trading a try ,through the help of _ambreymarcus1 I was able to earn R250,000 in 2 weeks thank you so much Mr _ambreymarcus1 .

Le Baloyi …. Madisha

Who takes big nose madontsela seriously? 🤮💩

Yes agree!!

I entrusted Vina_Redmon with my money since I took rush of investing my money with her platform, and since then I've recovered all I lost to scams. Get in touch with Vina_Redmon and get a good mentorship and safe trading.

She is jelous and useless, she failed to do a simple investigation , this one thinks that she is smart. Mandisa is a Judge not a fake professor.

I have benefited from at least R40k a week with williamchurch09 through his recommended platform with my small investment. Don't spend all your money without investing. williamchurch09 is a life saver, join me and win also in with good hands

And God knows why the establishment wants someone else not Maya🤷🏽‍♂️

Do these people get paid per article? Tweet? or are on a retainer?

Tell Thuli that she must tell the president to choose a person of his choice, he doesn’t need all these NGO and white media to lie about the proceedings of the interview. The establishment wants someone else just not Mandisa Maya qha

Stating the obvious. The JSC knows it too, the majority is just deliberately using Maya's candidacy to try frustrate the process with a recommendation that the President didn't ask for.

And I will agree with who saying Ramaphosa is a dictator

Then what is the use of those Interviews then

That will be judicial coup DE,tat if Ramaphosa doesn't appoint the recommended candidate

I know we all probably must have heard about Bitcoin but don't know how it works, I tried it in a week ago by a man who recommended me to Leticia_thomas4 on Twitter She guides me through and i made a return of R15500 after a week of trading, connect with her

We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here. Read more:

 /  🏆 28. in LAW

Law Law Latest News, Law Law Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

EUSEBIUS MCKAISER | Judge Mandisa Maya is fit and proper to be chief justice. The JSC is neither fit nor properIt is extremely unfortunate the recommendation that Mandisa Maya should become the next chief justice is marred by the incompetence of several commissioners sitting on the JSC, writes Eusebius McKaiser. Eusebius Nimtshele sithi msunu wenja ye stabani. Eusebius Commissioners should first be interviewed before sitting on the JSC. Commissioners should meet a certain criteria before qualifying to sit on the JSC nd they should follow certain guidelines in terms of questioning. Political questions shouldn't be allowed. Eusebius The JSC delivered the majority 23 commissioner vote favoring Maya for the position of CJ. Hope ThuliMadondela3 - who works for Stellenbosch - doesn't envy Maya's rise to the top of the judicial space in SA. Maya has already shattered the proverbial glass ceiling.
Source: SundayTimesZA - 🏆 47. / 51 Read more »

Politically fraught JSC interviews may face legal challengePolitically fraught JSC interviews may face legal challenge - President Cyril Ramaphosa is not bound by the recommendation put forth on Saturday by the JSC for the new chief justice Investing with williamchurch09 has brought my family so much joy, I've received R85,500 from my little funds i invested and I'm grateful, i advice everyone to invest with 👇👇👇👇 williamchurch09 I have benefited from at least R40k a week with williamchurch09 through his recommended platform with my small investment. Don't spend all your money without investing. williamchurch09 is a life saver, join me and win also in with good hands You need to read this
Source: mailandguardian - 🏆 2. / 92 Read more »

The next Chief Justice? Things to know about Judge Mandisa MayaThe next Chief Justice? Things to know about Judge Mandisa Maya The Judicial Service Commission (JSC) recently recommended that Judge Mandisa Maya be appointed Chief Justice
Source: TheSAnews - 🏆 25. / 59 Read more »

JSC responds to criticism about Chief Justice interview processWhile the Judicial Service Commission's recommended candidate for the country's Chief Justice, it's the process of getting to the recommendation that has als... Couple of months ago I came across a recommendation about Arnoldnike93 wealth how he helped investors to earn lots of money with their investments. and I decided to give a trial with the little I have. Now my little has turned into something great which was not my expectation
Source: SABCNews - 🏆 37. / 51 Read more »

'Another RET group': Malema accuses Lamola of influencing JSC interviewsZondo's JSC interview dissolved into chaos because of a heated verbal argument between Malema and Lamola. The EFF leader believes that the Minister of Justice manipulated the JSC to favour Zondo for the Chief Justice position. Read more 👇Malema Zondo
Source: brieflyza - 🏆 10. / 68 Read more »

Black Business Council supports JSC's recommendation of a female Chief JusticeThe JSC has recommended that President Cyril Ramaphosa appoints the Supreme Court of Appeal Judge President Mandisa Maya as Mogoeng Mogoeng's successor. Watching my daughters cry themselves to sleep because we dont have food cripples me as a man. I'm struggling to find employment and my family is suffering. Please assist us with any tinned food or food nearing their expiry date. For my children🙏🏻😔 If the president decides to appoint puppet of mainstream we will show him flames in in the ballot come 2024. He can go on and please his masters but he must also ask them to vote for him in 2024 coz we won't vote for an ANC which is anti black I know we all probably might have heard about Bitcoin but don't know how it works, I tried it in a week ago by a man who recommended me to Julie_fx_trader on Twitter she guides me through and i made a return of R66,000 after a week of trading, connect with her Julie_fx_trader
Source: ewnupdates - 🏆 30. / 53 Read more »