Supreme Court justices on abortion, during confirmation and from the bench

Justices’ comments during oral arguments are by no means determinative. Still, their remarks are closely parsed by reporters and legal observers for indications of which way they will ultimately come down on a case.

Here are some excerpts of the nine sitting justices from their Senate confirmation hearings and Wednesday’s oral arguments inThen “I know there are people of strongly held views on both sides of the issue. And I know that the responsibility of a judge confronting this issue is to decide the case according to the rule of law consistent with the precedents, not to take sides in a dispute as a matter of policy, but to decide it according to the law.”. That decision, that application of the principles ofis, of course, itself a precedent that would be entitled to respect under those principles.

“If you think that the issue is one of choice — that women should have a choice to terminate their pregnancy — that supposes that there is a point at which they’ve had the fair choice, opportunity to choose, and why would 15 weeks be an inappropriate line? Because viability, it seems to me, doesn’t have anything to do with choice.

“The problem with a super case like this, the rare case, the watershed case, where people are really opposed on both sides and they really fight each other, is they’re going to be ready to say ‘No you’re just political, you’re just politicians.’ And that’s what kills us as an American institution.”“I think that the legitimacy of the Court would be undermined in any case if the Court made a decision based on its perception of public opinion.

Can’t we have 12 Supreme Justices...Democrats?

At first I thought it was the voting and election tampering that would threaten our democracy. It turns out that it’s our Supreme Court Justices that will make or break our democracy. DIMmoCRAZY

Amazing the number of people that thing it is OK to rip an unborn child from the womb. How has the morals of the country go this low. It is a sad day that we think this is Ok. None has a right to this. It is midst. Plain a simple.

They didn’t even discussed how a young girl often gets raped by their own father or their own brother and they want them to carry this child till they give birth? So who honestly is abusing the law here? I believe it’s the justices, and people just like them!What do you think 🤔

I can hear the same bullshit at any Tim Horton's or Denny's.

Every conservative Justice pledged under oath that Roe was settled law during confirmation. If they lied, can there be repercussions?

In a short-time the Supreme Court will join the rest of the traditions and protocols we have kept sacred for over 250 years on the trash heap trump continues to fill. Let's just elect them and forget life appointments.

Horrifying that the U.S. Solicitor Gen. came very close to arguing that Plessy's 'separate but equal' holding could not have been overturned if the case was reargued 1 year later.

Everyone needs a license to practice medicine, except lawyers. 🎟🎪

The Court was fixed by Moscow Mitch and Trump.

We still do not know who owns Kavanaugh. Who bought his vote?

Term limits no public office should be lifetime. RBG was wonderful and stayed to long. Obama could have replaced instead of Amy. nyulaw YaleLawSch

5 old men dictating what 165,000,000 women can do with their bodies... What could possibly go wrong for the future of the Republican Party...

The is why evangelicals pretended Trump was a Christian and Obama wasn’t.

We really need to do away with this structure. The views held by these justices are wildly upopular. They do not represent the majority. How many of them were selected by a president who lost the popular vote?

I can’t believe in 2022 it will be illegal to have an abortion in half the US states 🤦🏼‍♂️

I feel like my Sunday will be better if I don’t start the day doing that

I dont want to - I know it will depress me. :(

If SCOTUS overrules the central ruling of Roe v. Wade, we'll know for certain that this Court is a militant Court. NoOneUnscripted

Law Law Latest News, Law Law Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

Father of autistic boy asks Supreme Court for emergency relief over TSA airline mask requirementThe father of a 4-year-old autistic boy is asking the Supreme Court for emergency action to block the Biden administration’s federal transportation mask mandate.
Source: FoxNews - 🏆 9. / 87 Read more »

Justice's adoption questioning draws controversy at Supreme Court abortion hearingWhen the U.S. Supreme Court heard arguments Wednesday over a Mississippi law that would ban most abortions after 15 weeks of pregnancy, a headline-making line of questioning came from the court's newest justice, Amy Coney Barrett. If you don’t want a kid just pull out, problem solved! nice Clearly these judges are selected from privileged stock Mom's may have had a D&c, coded properly. While impoverished women visited back room butchers. They would lynch a man, down the street. People feared the nonchalance of the privilege class. And republics hallow class warfare
Source: ABC - 🏆 471. / 51 Read more »

Nevada Supreme Court rules gunmakers not liable for Las Vegas concert shootingA Nevada law protects the gun manufacturers from culpability unless one of their firearms malfunctions. Why did your editorial staff decide to attach a photo of the Las Vegas shooting incident to an article about manufacturer liability? That's some real slick propaganda. Worse than that, this is deceitful manipulation. Insidious best describes your motives. ...as we watch daily our children being killed with guns. Only in America.
Source: Newsweek - 🏆 468. / 52 Read more »

This Supreme Court will gut Roe vs. Wade as only these justices canThe way these justices are likely to rule, the post-Roe reality for women and our politics looks grim, plus more from the week in Opinion. opinion Republicans are trying to turn this country over to the Christian mob. Not looking good for democracy. opinion European, ethno Hegemonist Fascists opinion Time to invest in wire hanger companies, because they are going to be used in a way not seen since the 1970’s. AbortionIsHealthcare
Source: latimes - 🏆 11. / 82 Read more »

The Supreme Court May Elevate the Second Amendment Above the FirstWhy should the Second Amendment’s protection extend to more places than the First Amendment’s? GTFOH. REBALANCESCOTUS Maybe start with don’t bring the gun. Exhibit A: Kyle Rittenhouse
Source: Slate - 🏆 716. / 51 Read more »

Majority of Supreme Court justices believe Roe ‘overstepped the bounds of law’NBC’s Pete Williams and legal analysts Melissa Murray and Joyce Vance join Chris Jansing to discuss Dobbs v. Jackson, one of the most important abortion cases in decades, which will be heard by the Supreme Court on Wednesday. “We now have five possibly six justices who are on record as believing that Roe is wrongly decided or at least overstepped the bounds of law,” says Vance. “And so the question is where this court will land.” JoyceWhiteVance This is why and how, a mentally demented majority gains control. The SCOTUS needs to be disbanded, and restructured by the people of the nation. Politics and Religious beliefs were never intended to rule the law. The SCOTUS has shown that their opinions and bias override the law. JoyceWhiteVance It’s time to get rid of the court system. It’s all a bunch of bullshit morgfair JoyceWhiteVance If they blow this, it will be the death knell for ANY real credibility going forward. For that, we can thank the Republicans and their ongoing battle with women.
Source: MSNBC - 🏆 469. / 51 Read more »