According to Paulie, Bananas and Jenny secretly hooked up in the bathroom during the season and it wasn’t caught on camera. “When you disappear in a bathroom for about 15, 20 minutes and then you’re cuddling for the next week afterward until he goes home, I mean, come on, what was he doing?” Paulie says.
“I think people are taking it very far and on behalf of the internet I’d like to apologize for how far they’re taking it,” Wes says. “It’s a game, it got me, and that’s where I kind of leave it.” Then Josh starts crying for how much that means to him, and Wes continues, “I know that people kind of blame Laurel and Josh for what happens, I do not, not one percent, literally zero percent, it is not their fault. It is all Bananas’ fault and he will pay.
That prompts Cara and Laurel to each tell their side of how their friendship ended: Cara says Laurel only wanted to be her friend when she was less confident and needed Laurel. But Laurel references a bad relationship that she tried to help Cara get out of . “I exited the friendship because it was too exhausting for me,” Laurel says. Cara says “there’s no hatred there” between them, but… yeah.Rogan is a straight-up d-bag for how he treated Dee, and the audience at the reunion feels the same.
And then a deleted scene from the season is shown where Rogan tells Paulie and Joss that he’s “bored” with Dee and how he “f—ed himself” by getting with Dee so quickly. He wanted to be single and have fun with “all the new Americans” he just met. And then Paulie says that Dee is a good number for them so Rogan has “got to keep f—ing her.” It’s all so gross. Dee keeps a great attitude about it all, cracking jokes at Rogan’s expense and how the No.